07 February 2012

{the Facebook debate} in my opinion anyway :::

Those of you who have been reading along for sometime know how I feel about Facebook.
For those of you who haven't, go do some light reading.


My dear friend Jo recently tried again at the social media giant that has an uncanny resemblance to an episode of Days of our Lives or Bold and the Beautiful. 
She blogged about her struggles over here. 
She shared some great points but she made one that sticks with me is, 


                                 "because I don't want my son's remembering
                                             their childhood as having a mother who
                                    was glued to her phone or her computer..."'


Wow. Simple. But some of us just don't realise it. Those who are continually "taking breaks" from these social media giants (again..THIS WAS ME!) may need to stop and realise that they may need to get rid of them for good! It's not a weakness!




Reading a recent article here, the writer summed it up perfectly by saying that "Facebook provides a skewed view of what's really going on." 
Yes I am aware that this article was referring to youth, but in actual fact sometimes us women are even more immature than the immature themselves. Can I get an amen?!

Other mothers 'perfect-while-teething' children playing happily with their siblings whilst mother makes a four course meal. Little did she care to inform you in her Facebook status that Mr 3 bit Mr 6's baby finger til it bled and she burnt two of the four courses because Miss 6mths had been crying hysterically with a fever for over 2 hours.
Meanwhile "real" mothers are sitting in the mess that is their life, wondering why their days aren't as perfect as hers. 
Ring a bell?!


I know it sounds awfully negative over here today, and I do try to provide a happy space over here at Mrs.Clark, but sometimes things need to be said.


Apart from the obvious link Facebook and other social media may have to depression, something else I just cannot get my head around is how on earth so many mothers find the time to spend on Facebook, Tweeting, Instagraming, Googleplus-ing, blogging etc.

I'm all for socialising, trust me! And I really do enjoy the ease of social networking but its those who are on every single one of them that really get me!  
The truth of the matter is that they actually don't have the time. 
I know. I used to be one of them.


I haven't been on Facebook for 8 months now. 
And apart from the odd few opinions of some narcissists in my world, most people are surprised and somewhat respectful of the fact that I've separated myself from one of the very causes of the painful journey I've walked in the last 2 years. 


I can't help but wonder what happened. 
When did it all go so wrong?
When did pointless status updates and poking around peoples pages take priority over actually living life?
When did sharing every mundane part of our day become so important?
When did bagging out people and sharing our opinion about every. single. thing. become so "cool"?


I'll leave you with this passage from a book I'm reading entitled "She's Not Your Competition" written by two amazing women Kelley Chisholm and Penny Webb from my church


"A further concern is the rise of social media in it's application as an immediate forum to compete with and intimidate others. Though most often associated with young women, it is showing up in all demographics - and has the potential to destroy relationships and peoples self-esteem but at an arms length and even anonymously."


Ain't that the truth!


I'm open to opinions so please share! 
Ugly, unnecessary & nasty comments will be deleted. 


xoxo

27 shared some love:

  1. Whoops! I'm on fb, have a blog, and use instagram. I have children? Wha? That must be what all that background noise is ;)

    Xo em

    Glad the detox is working for you xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's all balance! If you can do it and it doesn't make you feel like crap then props to ya! And you seem to do it gorgeously xxx

      Delete
  2. Thanks for this post. I've been wanting to delete my Facebook and just havent yet. I go back and forth. But this is the encouragement I needed to end it. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So glad it helped! It's really hard to pull the plug, so to speak. But when its the right thing for you then you know straight away! xxxx

      Delete
    2. Hey, I pulled the plug a few days ago and it feels so good ;) Sorry your kiddo got sick though ;(

      Delete
  3. So glad it helped! It's really hard to pull the plug, so to speak. But when its the right thing for you then you know straight away! xxxx

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi, I'm brand new to your blog! I just found it via Dee's blog-your Tiny eyes doll in those beautiful photos-et voila your blog :) And this post really speaks to me...I've been feeling guilty for exactly.the.same reasons! Sitting down to check facebook for '5 minutes' and being there for an hour. I've always disregarded quitting because I live so far away from my family. But then...there are always other ways of communicating... food for thought. Thanks so much for sharing your honest processing... remaliah

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Remaliah! First let me say I completely understand about the family thing! I have a step sister in South Africa and family spread all over the globe and I've toyed with the idea of having a Facebook page just for us to stay connected but never have gone through with it. And that was always what happened to me - the 5 minutes turned 1 hour thing. And it's scary how quick the time would go when I was on FB! Thanks for following along and thank you for your comments on our photos, Tim is a talent and the dolls Dee made are my absolute favourite items in my kids rooms! xxx

      Delete
  5. You have my Amen. I was off Facebook after my depression for 6 months and can't say I ever missed it! Well I had an account but I just never went on there. This year I made a decision to use it again for a business tool but I've found myself on there personally occasionally too and it's just gunk for our brains! And I spend way too much time on the computer as it is just keeping my own "diary" etc and get the mother's guilts for it. A lot of it for me is business which I can't really change but a fair amount of it isn't as well.
    However, while I keep my own blog almost daily, shock horror I actually rarely make the time to read other's these days. It's just too much... I see mine these days as my online diary but not as much of a social networking thing as it once was. Good on you for recognising the detromental effect of social networking in your own life.
    Thus all being said, I don't think we can assume that it's necessarily always unhealthy for other people. I guess it's up to them to decide that...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh Kat Facebook is a Godsend for small (and quickly growing ;) business' huh? Of course you need it for business reasons! I so agree! It's those little lost personal moments that are the killer. And you are absolutely right, it's not a problem for everyone. It's one of those things hey? It's based on each individual. xxx

      Delete
    2. I read it now and I survived but I.still.don't.know :( . It is in the too hard basket. I don't have many friends I see "in the flesh". It is a habit that is so very hard to break! Being on the phone so much! Ahhh! Yet here I am. I.still.don't.know

      Delete
  6. A new follower ... 'hello!'
    I agree .. You can read so much into status updates .. Who knows what really goes on behind closed doors! Im on FB, I blog and am on Instagram .. My excuse I have a 7 week old and it fills the time while breastfeeding do much!! Haha

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh I remember those long nights breast feeding and YES it was all a blessing..Facebook, Twitter, blogs. Ahhhh! Sweet memories! Congratulations on your baby and thanks for stoppin by! xxxx

      Delete
  7. Thanks for the reality check - "because I don't want my son's remembering their childhood as having a mother who was glued to her phone or her computer..."' !!
    I think you are right, we don't have time for everything and it is SO time consuming keeping up with all the social network stuff {that i know}. I have dumped facebook and we are having one completely 'tech' free day a week in our house, but i don't think i could give up twitter or instagram yet! thankfully i am finding a balance to it all.
    You got me thinking. xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love the tech free day idea! How great is that?! What I love about Instagram is the beauty and the fact that it causes us to intentionally stop and capture the moments that we would have otherwise lost. I agree! Instagram ain't going anywhere for me either! xxx

      Delete
  8. I agree with Jody - thanks for the reality check. That sentence is very powerful and a great reminder of how we should be. When my kids aren't asleep I try to ignore that burning desire to check emails one more time or have another quick Instagram check. Scary how addictive it can all be really. Good on you for letting go.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks Anna! Emails.. Augh! I get that burning desire too! Agreed. Sometimes when the kids are asleep and I'm all tucked up in bed I fall asleep checking instagram and emails..my wake up call is when my phone falls out of my hand! So sad.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I took a 2 month sabbatical from FB last year in the lead up to Christmas. It was so helpful for me to re-evaluate what I really needed and what I didn't. Truthfully, I do like Facebook for keeping in touch with far flung family and friends, I could use email for that, but would have to do it individually and it would probs take more time than FB. So when I returned I did a massive cull and left it only with people I really wanted to see. It has made a huge difference. I also, sometimes, have my husband take the internet cord to work with him as it's not just FB that sucks my time, "researching" recipes, patterns and the like is a big trap for me!! I also use my husbands Ipod for instagram, so that also goes during the day! Just gotta go with what feels best for you though. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I'm not a huge fan of FB. I have an acct., and get on there for a few minutes about every other day. I mostly keep it to stay (somewhat) connected with friends/faraway family. But I really don't care that much for it.
    I do, however, like Twitter & Instagram. I'm not on them a ton, but I much prefer them to FB. I think it's all about maintaining a good balance. Naturally, my family, friends and "real" life must come first, but I've also made some really wonderful friends (who are now real life friends) through those platforms and they have also helped me to grow my business. We just have to be committed to keeping our priorities straight.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I absolutely 100% agree! I've been off Facebook for about 2 years and I love it! It really is so dramatic and so trivial. Yes there are many advantages Luke keeping I'm touch with far away friends, but to me, the enemy usually gets more of a foothold than God does. Love this. Keep on keeping on!

    Brooke

    Thebebebirds.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. What a great post. I've deleted it before for over 2 years. I joined back up again when I had my daughter. It was so I could share photos of her with family/friends as I was a proud new mum. But it also proved to me that the nickname hubby and I use for it "Brag Book" is too true!
    We are generally complaining or bragging on facebook as a general population aren't we? I agree that it creates an unrealistic and competitive environment.
    Thanks for spurring me on - I've deleted it off my iPhone and will continue to use self control when 'logging on'!
    I have a rule of not being on the phone or computer at all when my daughter is awake. It is unnecessary, unfair and not something I want her to remember me for or learn as a habit herself! :) I use my blog as a motivation to create fun learning activities for her and share them with other parents as well as some of the other things I enjoy doing! I think that's a positive use of technology!
    Thanks again for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  14. haha! That turned out to be quite a rant! Whoops! Perhaps I should do a blog post on it too! xxx haha!

    ReplyDelete
  15. I am taking a break from fb and all social networking ......including Instagram. IG became my new fb and if I'm honest I liked it mostly because I was pretty anonymous in the world of IG. And also if I'm honest I think IG is wonderful but I think it is as much as a bragging medium as fb. There were posts I had put up of crafting mornings we had that looked wonderful at the time, but 5 mins after a fight would break out or something would burn - not always but sometimes. Pictures, while inspiring and beautiful, can at times be very deceiving. I think we have to be careful of anything in life that distracts or detracts from the life God wants for us.........lots of things can consume you in life.....it's all about good rhythm. It's not black and white. But yes be brave to cut ties or take breaks to take a check on things :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. People think that if they delete FB they will miss out on so much, or won't be able to communicate with others. Since I gave FB the flick, I have seen my friendships deepen, rather then spreading myself thin with all the 'friends' on FB. There are so many different ways to communicate besides FB - email, heytell, whatsapp, text messaging, writing a letter, speaking on the phone and blogging.

    I love that you said, "It's not a weakness." Facebook really does provide a skewed view of the world. You are not missing out on anything by not being on it. In fact, you have probably gained more than the people that are in denial about just unhealthy FB is, or can't bring themselves to delete their account.

    Love you my 'little sis' Jo xoxoxo

    ReplyDelete
  17. I love this post Stacey - its not negative at all. I admit I do have a facebook account - not for meaningless status updates though - really just to share photos with family and friends who seem to live all over the country and the world; however, I also like to monitor my kids usage and their friends and so I am a regular 'checker' of their pages, I think it is my responsibility more than anything else .

    The message you send needs to be spread far and wide for sure... and posts like these need to appear more often - well done.

    xx Tam

    ReplyDelete
  18. wow! this was such a timely post for me. thank you so much for challenging me to take a step back and really look at my life and how my time is spent on a daily basis. :) lora

    ReplyDelete

I do try and respond to all comments but sometimes the reality of motherhood sets in and I just can't get back to each of you. But do know that I read EVERY comment and appreciate them all!